When I first started playing the guitar, one question that constantly nagged me was: What should I use as a guitar pick? I mean, does it always have to be the conventional plastic pick, or can I get creative? Over the years, I’ve experimented with different materials and objects, some conventional and some not so much. Let’s embark on this journey together as we explore the different options for guitar picks, their characteristics, and even touch on some of the stranger household items that budding musicians have used in place of a conventional guitar pick.
The Conventional Plastic Pick
Shapes and Sizes
Picks come in various shapes and sizes. The traditional teardrop shape is perhaps the most popular, but there are also options like sharkfin, triangular, or jazz-shaped picks that cater to specific playing styles. The size and thickness of the pick, ranging from ultra-thin to heavy, have a significant impact on playability and the produced sound.
Materials
The majority of picks are made from various types of plastics, but other materials are also utilized. Common materials include:
- Nylon: Known for its flexibility and durability, nylon picks are favored by many players for their smooth attack.
- Celluloid: This material offers a natural feel and warm tone, closely resembling the properties of natural tortoiseshell.
- Delrin: A type of acetal resin, Delrin picks are known for their stiffness and slick surface, providing a bright tone.
- Acrylic: Acrylic picks are often harder and denser, delivering a sharp and clear sound.
- Polycarbonate: These picks have a rigid feel and offer a bright tone with excellent durability.
- Bone: Bone picks provide a unique texture and resonance, adding a distinctive character to your playing. They are known for their hardness and can offer a sharp attack.
The choice of material will heavily influence the pick’s feel, resistance, and the tonal quality it imparts on the strings. Experimenting with different materials, including both traditional plastics and unique substances like bone, can lead to discovering the perfect pick that fits your playing style and the genre of music you prefer.
Creative and Unconventional Picks
Using a Coin
A common alternative to a plastic pick is a coin. Many players ask, “Can I use a coin as a guitar pick?” The answer is yes, but with caution. The rigidity of a coin can produce a brighter, more metallic sound. However, it can also wear down your strings faster. Hilariously enough, some famous guitarists have even been known to prefer coins for their unique feel and tone! Queen’s guitarist, Brian May for example, famously used a sixpence coin. His technique made the coin a vital part of his unique sound.
Other Objects
Believe it or not, I’ve used credit cards, paper clips, and even the lids of containers. These materials can produce unique sounds, but they might not be suitable for every playing style.
In addition, please keep in mind that these random objects in your home or wallet can cause more wear and tear on the strings or guitar surface, so I would only suggest experimenting with some of these if you are in a bind.
The Impact of Thickness
Thin Picks
Thin picks, usually below 0.60mm, are more flexible. They’re excellent for strumming but may not provide the precision required for intricate lead playing.
Medium Picks
Medium picks, ranging from 0.60mm to 0.80mm, offer a balanced feel and sound. They’re suitable for various playing styles.
Thick Picks
Thick picks, above 0.80mm, are typically favored by lead guitarists. Their rigidity allows for more control and precision but may not be ideal for rhythm playing.
The Impact of Material
Plastic
As mentioned, plastic is the most common material for picks. Different types of plastics provide a variety of tones, from warm to bright.
Metal
Metal picks, including coins, offer a very bright and aggressive tone. They are durable but can be harsh on strings and require a careful approach.
Wood and Bone
Wood and bone picks provide a warm, natural sound. They’re often used in acoustic performances.
Finding Your Perfect Pick
Finding the perfect pick may require experimentation. I’ve spent hours trying different shapes, sizes, and materials to find what works best for me.
Your playing style is a crucial element in determining the best pick. Are you into strumming, lead playing, or a mix of both? Your pick should complement your style.
The Price Factor: From Affordable to Luxury
Pricing is of course, another important thing to think about when considering a style of pick. While the vast majority of picks most musicians purchase are quite cheap, there can be some significant variability.
Affordable Options
Standard plastic picks are quite affordable, and you can often buy them in bulk. It makes experimenting with different types and shapes accessible to most players.
Luxury Picks
On the other hand, some picks are made from luxurious materials like precious metals or exotic woods. These picks can be quite expensive but offer unique characteristics and can even be seen as status symbols among musicians.
The Best Picks: A Comparison of Three Distinct Choices
Picks play a crucial role in defining your tone and playing experience, and with countless options on the market, choosing the right one can be a daunting task. Here, I’ll introduce you to three distinct picks, each with unique characteristics, that I’ve found to represent different aspects of quality, price, and playability.
1. Dunlop Tortex Standard
- Price: Affordable
- Quality: High
- Material: Delrex
- Thickness: Variety of options (from .50mm to 1.14mm)
- Features: Standard shape with a matte finish for better grip
- Best For: Versatile use, suitable for various styles and genres
- My Experience: The Dunlop Tortex picks are a staple among guitarists. Their affordability combined with durability makes them an excellent choice for beginners and professionals alike. I’ve used these picks for everything from strumming to soloing.
2. Fender Premium Celluloid
- Price: Mid-range
- Quality: High
- Material: Celluloid
- Thickness: Various options (Thin, Medium, Heavy)
- Features: Traditional feel, often with beautiful tortoiseshell patterns
- Best For: Those who want a classic tone and appearance
- My Experience: The Fender Premium Celluloid picks offer a timeless look and a warm tone. I appreciate the way they mimic the feel of the original tortoiseshell picks without the ethical concerns. Their slightly higher price is justified by their aesthetic appeal and the unique tonal characteristics they offer.
3. BlueChip Picks
- Price: Luxury
- Quality: Exceptional
- Material: Proprietary material (Vespel)
- Thickness: Customizable
- Features: Highly durable, often used by professional musicians
- Best For: Those looking for a long-lasting pick with superior playability
- My Experience: The BlueChip Picks are an investment. Their proprietary material offers a playing experience unlike any other pick I’ve tried. They feel great, last incredibly long, and provide a consistency in tone that is hard to match. These picks are for those who are serious about their gear and are willing to pay a premium for quality.
The world of guitar picks is vast, with options to suit every playing style, aesthetic preference, and budget. From the affordable and reliable Dunlop Tortex to the luxurious and unparalleled BlueChip Picks, your choice will undoubtedly influence your playing experience. Whether you’re a beginner looking for a versatile option or an experienced musician seeking something unique, these three picks cover a broad spectrum and offer something for everyone. Remember, experimenting with different picks is part of the journey, and these choices can be a great starting point.
Custom Picks and Personal Preferences
Custom-made Picks
Did you know that you can have picks custom-made to your preferences? Whether it’s a specific material, shape, or even a personalized logo, custom picks can be a fun way to express your individuality.
Textures and Grips
Different textures and grips on picks can enhance the playing experience. From smooth to textured surfaces, these variations influence how the pick feels between your fingers.
The Health Aspect: Picks and Ergonomics
Comfort and Playability
Finding a pick that’s comfortable to hold and play with for extended periods is vital. The right pick can prevent unnecessary strain on your fingers and wrist.
Adapting to Physical Needs
For those with specific physical needs or limitations, customized picks are available. These adaptations ensure that everyone can enjoy playing the guitar, regardless of physical challenges.
Understanding the Connection Between Picks and Genres
Rock and Metal
In genres like rock and metal, I’ve often found that thicker and harder picks, sometimes even metal ones, are preferred. These picks provide the necessary attack and precision required for fast and aggressive playing.
Jazz
Jazz players often opt for smaller, thicker picks that offer more control over dynamics. It helps them to articulate those complex jazz chords and melodies.
Acoustic and Folk
For strumming chords in acoustic or folk music, I’ve realized that a thinner, more flexible pick often does the job best. It provides a softer attack and lets the natural tone of the acoustic guitar shine through.
Conclusion
Navigating through the options of what to use for a guitar pick can be both exciting and overwhelming. From traditional picks to unconventional alternatives like coins, your choice will significantly impact your playing style and the sounds you create. In this exploration, we’ve delved into the nuances of different pick materials, their effect on playability, and even the ethical considerations that some materials present. By comparing three top picks, we’ve also shed light on how various factors such as price, quality, and material can influence your decision.
Don’t hesitate to experiment with different options, and may your choice of pick be a catalyst for creativity, enhancing your connection to the music. Whether a beginner or a seasoned pro, I hope this guide serves as a valuable resource in your musical journey, helping you find the pick that resonates with you. Happy strumming!
Frequently Asked Questions
Q1: What should I use as a guitar pick?
A: You can use a traditional guitar pick made of materials like celluloid, nylon, or metal. Unconventional options like coins or DIY picks cut from plastic cards are also possible, but consider how they will affect your sound and playing experience.
Q2: Can I use a coin as a guitar pick?
A: Yes, you can use a coin as a guitar pick, but it’s typically harder and can produce a brighter, more metallic sound. It may also wear down your strings more quickly. Experiment with different coins to find one that suits your style.
Q3: How do I choose the best pick for my playing style?
A: Consider factors like thickness, material, shape, and texture. A thicker pick might be better for heavy strumming, while a thinner one could be suitable for intricate picking. Trying different picks and assessing how they feel and sound will guide you to the best choice for your style.
Q4: Are there eco-friendly guitar pick options?
A: Yes! There are picks made from recycled materials, biodegradable plastics, and even wood. If environmental considerations are important to you, look for brands that offer eco-friendly picks.
Q5: How often should I replace my guitar pick?
A: The frequency of replacing your guitar pick depends on how much you play, the material of the pick, and your playing style. A pick that has become thin, brittle, or jagged should be replaced, as it might negatively affect your playing and sound.
Q6: What are the main differences between traditional picks and unconventional picks like coins?
A: Traditional picks are designed to cater to various playing styles and sounds, while unconventional picks, such as coins, offer unique tonal characteristics. A coin may produce a more metallic sound and be less comfortable to hold, but some players appreciate these distinctive qualities.
Q7: Is it necessary to use a pick when playing the guitar?
A: No, it’s not necessary to use a pick; many guitarists prefer fingerpicking or using their fingernails. The choice between using a pick or not depends on the sound you want to achieve and what feels comfortable for you.
Q8: Can I make my own guitar pick?
A: Absolutely! Many guitarists make their own picks from old credit cards, gift cards, or other pieces of plastic. There are also pick punch tools available that allow you to create custom picks from various materials.